The real difference is the record color, not the tracklist
Both the Curtain Red and standard versions of the Five Nights at Freddy's 2 Vinyl Soundtrack deliver the same score by The Newton Brothers, pressed for physical release by iam8bit with Universal and Blumhouse. The catalog describes the music the same way for each: kinetic, creepy, and whimsical, with haunting vocal choruses and synthwave pulses. If you are choosing between them, you are really choosing a color variant and a price point, not a different listening experience.
The Curtain Red edition is explicitly pressed on Curtain Red Vinyl. The standard listing does not name a vinyl color in the supplied record, so treat its color as unconfirmed rather than assuming black or any other specific shade. That distinction matters if the look of the record is part of why you are buying.
Catalog evidence: Curtain Red and standard
- Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 Vinyl Soundtrack (Retail Curtain Red): Pressed on Curtain Red Vinyl. The color is the headline difference for collectors who display or photograph their records.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 Vinyl Soundtrack (Retail Curtain Red) - Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 Vinyl Soundtrack: The standard listing is offered as One Random, with a Quantity option. If you want a specific look, the Curtain Red listing is the one that names its color; the standard listing's random option adds uncertainty.

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 Vinyl Soundtrack - Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 Vinyl Soundtrack (Retail Curtain Red): Catalog price is USD 19.51, compared with a catalog comparison price of USD 31.99. At the time of writing, the Curtain Red variant is the lower-priced named-color option in the catalog.
- Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 Vinyl Soundtrack: Catalog price is USD 23.99, compared with a catalog comparison price of USD 31.99. The standard listing costs more than the Curtain Red listing in the catalog, so color preference is not the only trade-off.
Cover variants: four designs, but not a listing difference
Both listings describe four collectible variant covers designed by Scott Saslow, each featuring a different animatronic horror. The catalog does not say which cover comes with which listing, or whether you can choose a specific cover at checkout. That means the cover is a shared feature of the release, not a reliable way to tell the two listings apart. If a particular animatronic cover is essential to you, ask before ordering rather than assuming the product image guarantees it.
Side-by-side: what each listing confirms
- Curtain Red (product 1606431): Named Curtain Red Vinyl color; catalog price USD 19.51; four Scott Saslow cover variants described; same Newton Brothers score and iam8bit physical release.
- Standard (product 1606405): Vinyl color not named in the supplied record; offered as One Random with a Quantity option; catalog price USD 23.99; same score and four cover variants described.
What the catalog does not tell you
Neither listing supplies track count, run time, record weight, jacket type, or a confirmed vinyl color for the standard edition. The Curtain Red listing also does not state a limited pressing quantity. These are real gaps if you are a collector who cares about specs, so do not read this comparison as a full specification sheet. The safest reading is that the two listings share the same soundtrack release and differ in the details shown above.
How to choose between them
If the red record is the reason you are interested, the Curtain Red listing is the direct match because it is the only one that names its color. It also costs less in the catalog at the moment. If you are indifferent to color and simply want the FNaF 2 soundtrack on vinyl, the standard listing is a valid alternative, but its One Random option means you should not expect a specific variant. Either way, you are getting the same score, so let color and price decide rather than the cover art, which the catalog describes identically for both.



